Debt recovery has always been challenging but things can get more complicated when a debtor pays the original outstanding invoice but disputes the additional debt-recovery costs, which we add on in some cases. When dealing with debt recovery, clear credit terms, proper documentation, and consistent documented communications play an important role in resolving these scenarios successfully.
In a recent case, despite a debtor’s initial resistance and a dispute over the recovery fees, Slater Byrne Recoveries (SBR) successfully recovered $30k for its client. This consisted of the original debt owed of $30k, and an additional amount of debt-recovery costs of approximately $3k.

A Challenging but Winnable Case
A business specialising in luxury goods engaged us to pursue an outstanding debt owed by a customer in the jewellery industry. The debt arose from an order for custom-made jewellery.
The client asserted that the luxury goods could not simply be returned as they had been custom-made. The client also added that the customer previously indicated their intention was to pay, but that they had become difficult to contact and had completely stopped responding. Hence, after many unsuccessful attempts to resolve the matter directly over a number of months, the client referred the debt to us.
Upon receiving the matter, Slater Byrne Recoveries conducted a company search through ASIC and issued a formal demand notice. This was followed with SMS’s and phone calls. The customer then raised their desire to return the custom-made goods and requested more time to pay. SBR explained the general position on returning goods, particularly where the items have been custom-made and explained the consequences of non payment to the debtor. We warned them of potential legal action and also credit defaults would could be lodged and would have a serious impact on their company.
Just 2 weeks after being engaged to chase the debt, the client confirmed that the customer had paid the original invoice amount of $30k, directly to them.
However, the debt-recovery cost of $3k was not settled and remained unpaid.
Resolving the Outstanding Balance through Persistence
Slater Byrne Recoveries reviewed all the documentation and requested further information from the client to verify the applicable terms for the passing on of recovery fees to their customer. With all of these in hand, SBR was able to explain the basis of the recovery costs to the customer and the fact that they were now liable to pay these fees.
SBR continued pursuing the disputed recovery costs through a structured follow-up process: a reminder notice was issued on 28 September 2026, followed by a credit-default warning on 6 October, and a notice of intention to commence proceedings (warning that commencement of legal action would occur if payment is not made within 7 days of the notice being issued) on 13 October.
Throughout the whole process, SBR maintained its position on the outstanding recovery costs. The documented credit terms provided an important reference point when addressing the customer’s objections on paying the remaining balance.
On 13 October 2026, the remaining $3,100.84 was eventually received from the customer, resulting to a successful resolution and recovery of the full debt and all costs in just over three weeks.
The Key Takeaways
This case highlights important considerations for managing overdue accounts.
- Terms and Conditions should always be clear and kept on file.
Clearly documented terms help establish the basis for recovering collection costs that are legally enforceable.
- Consistent follow-up makes a difference.
A structured process involving payment demands, reminders, and escalation, helps successful resolution.
- Facts and solid communication matter when fees are disputed.
When a customer questions a recovery charge having the right documentation in place supports more informed discussion and positive turnout.
- Where a debt is disputed, the recovery costs may not be recoverable and our process of addressing the costs will differ to the above scenario.
This case demonstrates how a structured debt recovery process and clear communication and documentation can help businesses pursue overdue accounts and resolve disputes successfully without our client ending up out of pocket at all for the entire process. Individual cases will vary and we will provide you with our tailored advice to your specific case.
Need help in recovering an outstanding debt? If your business is dealing with unpaid invoices, customers who are difficult to contact, Slater Byrne Recoveries can help you navigate the debt collection process with a professional approach.
Contact us now to discuss your business’ debt recovery needs!
